My family comes from India. Most of the time this means nothing to me. In fact, I've noted with some frustration that many people have misplaced pride in their ancestry. Sure, it's kind of cool to see Vishy Anand as the world chess champion, and whenever I see an Indian athlete I'll be sure to cheer for him (My jokes belie my pride). But apart from that, without a doubt I consider myself an American. There are, of course, experiences I share with first-generation Asian kids. Among them, and I cringe at the implied meaning, is my "Asian parents."
That phrase has come to stand for a very specific idea in today's culture, and perhaps especially among my peers. In this particular instance, I would like to consider Asian parents in a different light. The other attribute that Asian parents share, other than being angry and unreasonable, is that they all moved to the United States from Asia.
My grandparents have almost all passed away. It's sad to think about, but as a uni-lingual American I could not communicate with them well. My mom tells her mom if I accomplish something, and she tells me that her mom says congratulations. It's really not the same. I'm ashamed to admit it, but she almost doesn't seem real to me.
But I remember the death of my dad's mother. She was diagnosed with pancreatic cancer. I remember how panicked my dad was. He researched the diagnosis for days. He spent hours on the phone trying to track down a top-notch doctor for her. He was distracted from his work, distracted from his life here. It was obvious that he wanted to be back in India, by her side ...
What was he doing here? I asked myself that question many times. Of course, he left for India as soon as possible, but my question still lingered. Why was he in the United States at all? Why separate himself from someone he cared for so much? It was heartbreaking to watch him suffer, although I must be wary of using such a term, since my pain was nothing compared to his.
My immediate answer was what I think is the most natural one - he came to study. With his acceptance into graduate school he was probably assured a reasonable job if he finished. But then why didn't he return to India upon completing his degree? At least by today's standards, that seems to be relatively common practice.
The answer, which may be obvious to some of you, is that he wanted to ensure a better future for his family. He wanted to make sure that they wouldn't grow up in the same poor town that he did, in the same thief-ridden environment that he called home for the first 20 years of his life. In short, he did it for me.
How do you repay a lifetime of sacrifice? It sounds so trivial when you just say "immigrants gave up everything to come to this country." The cliche makes it sound as if they are a part of the distant past. But in truth there is no better way to say it - his friends, his life, but most importantly, his family were all left 8000 miles behind. And while he went on to have an impressive career in academia, his new family has always remained first and foremost. I consider myself fortunate that when he grows old, I will be able to take care of him. That when he calls I will be there in seconds, not 72 hours. This isn't "repaying" by any means. Nor does it have to be. That's what it means, I think, to give up everything for someone else. Repayment isn't necessary - only appreciation.
I carry the burden of his hopes and dreams for his family. The burden of making something of myself, so that his sacrifice will have meaning. I'm happy to carry that burden. Happy to have the opportunity to show the world that my parents, in spite of all the challenges they had to face, were able to succeed not only in their careers but also as a family. In fact, I would go so far as to say that I'm proud to carry that burden.
That's what it means to have Asian pride.
Tuesday, May 31, 2011
Impurity
I think we're all familiar with the concept of intrinsic vs. extrinsic motivation. If not, this is a post that discusses the difference as well as I ever could (among other topics). Let me be the first to say that in my perfect world, we'd all be intrinsically motivated to the highest degree. However, life has an irritating habit of messing around with such ideals. We meet other brilliant people. We learn from them, but occasionally we are also a little bit intimidated by them. So here's my interim solution - it isn't perfect, but it's the best I've got.
----------------------------------------------
Recently, chess has once again piqued my interested. I've shown up at a few tournaments, performed at least reasonably well, and had a good time learning from my mistakes.
It's inevitable, I suppose, that these adventures evoke memories of when I was a sixth grader. I was one of the top chess players in the area. I crushed adults, and the high school players all talked about how they wanted to avoid me. If ever I have been proud of myself, it was then. I was, in my small community, the best.
Of course, it's never that easy. I quit chess soon after, and the people I was once on par with sprinted past me. When I rejoined the scene in part 3 years later, my "peers" had fought their way upwards with great success, and I was once more a mediocre fish in a big, big pond.
I think to some degree, everyone wants to be special. I hope I'm not just projecting my own desires onto other people here, but posts like this give me reason to think that I'm not. Unfortunately, we can't all be the best at whatever we're doing. There's also something that makes being the worst at what we do unacceptable to us (thankfully). So being "special" in these two ways is really not an option to the vast majority of us.
When you read about or come across someone who is our age and has output 3 research papers, or played in Carnegie Hall, or gotten a full-time job at Google, congratulate them. Marvel at their brilliance, and be inspired by their perseverance. But don't stop there. Take it upon yourself to reach their level of dedication and achievement. I feel like the moment you do that ... that's when you become special.
----------------------------------------------
Recently, chess has once again piqued my interested. I've shown up at a few tournaments, performed at least reasonably well, and had a good time learning from my mistakes.
It's inevitable, I suppose, that these adventures evoke memories of when I was a sixth grader. I was one of the top chess players in the area. I crushed adults, and the high school players all talked about how they wanted to avoid me. If ever I have been proud of myself, it was then. I was, in my small community, the best.
Of course, it's never that easy. I quit chess soon after, and the people I was once on par with sprinted past me. When I rejoined the scene in part 3 years later, my "peers" had fought their way upwards with great success, and I was once more a mediocre fish in a big, big pond.
I think to some degree, everyone wants to be special. I hope I'm not just projecting my own desires onto other people here, but posts like this give me reason to think that I'm not. Unfortunately, we can't all be the best at whatever we're doing. There's also something that makes being the worst at what we do unacceptable to us (thankfully). So being "special" in these two ways is really not an option to the vast majority of us.
When you read about or come across someone who is our age and has output 3 research papers, or played in Carnegie Hall, or gotten a full-time job at Google, congratulate them. Marvel at their brilliance, and be inspired by their perseverance. But don't stop there. Take it upon yourself to reach their level of dedication and achievement. I feel like the moment you do that ... that's when you become special.
Sunday, May 8, 2011
Liquid
Today was the "Official Foosball Banquet" for our club. We got together, played foosball (what else?), went to get dinner at a fancy (by our standards) restaurant, and then played foosball until they kicked us out of the game room. Really the only abnormal part of the evening was the restaurant choice. We've had that night many times. But tonight we were celebrating the departure of two of our members, so it was a bittersweet occasion.
Without a doubt, I'll miss them. Foosball club will of course not be the same. We're a dying breed, so to speak. The two of them represent a full third of our regular members. I'm don't really interact with them outside of the foosball tables, and with my recent boycott of facebook, keeping in touch will be difficult. So when they walked in the opposite direction to their homes, it occurred to me that I would probably never see them again.
Plopping myself down in front of my computer, I clicked through the three sites I check on a regular basis now: chessgames.com, riveraveblues.com, and teamliquid.net.
According to my profile, I registered an account on Teamliquid (TL) on October 4, 2008. I lurked the forums for a few months prior to that, so it's been almost three years since I first visited. At the time it was a close-knit group, focused on the professional scene of Korean Starcraft. There were the forum giants, who had accumulated 20,000 posts over 6 years. There were the villains of the board, who sought to "troll" at every given opportunity. It was a site to fall in love with because of its familiarity and common goal: forming a community.
Thousands upon thousands of man-hours went into that site. Whether it was a comprehensive analysis of the latest "revolution" in Terran versus Zerg or an endless list of "yo mama" jokes filled with the most topical Korean Broodwar references, the posts all had a cleverness and a certain charm behind them. I spent hours reading the forums. TL became my source for all news - not just the Starcraft variety. I knew that someone would always have an interesting take, or something funny to say, or at the very least, some lively debate to kick off.
I'll never say that all the time I've spent reading TL were wasted. They didn't really get me many places, per se. I'm not a better mathematician because of them. I'm probably not even a more informed person. All those hours run completely contrary to common definitions of productivity. So maybe it wasn't the best use of time.
Claiming that all that time was useless, however, could not be further from the truth. I learned so much about people. I was taught how to see the funny things in life. I saw first-hand where effort and determination could get you. I was inspired by the people dedicating their lives to an online service that was free of charge, all for the sake of a single passion.
But today I came home, sad at the prospect of never seeing the seniors again. Sad, but not crushed. People come and go in our lives, this much is inevitable. And as hard as it is to say, not everyone can be with us forever. So I thought to myself - if I can say goodbye to Steve and David, can't I say goodbye to TL?
It was a startling connection to make. Why would I stop visiting the site I've probably spent more than 10 hours per week on for the last 3 years? It's not like I was being forced into the situation, the way the departure of the seniors was forced upon me. The reasons were blatantly obvious, though. The community had changed, there were many new members, there are a whole host of things I should be doing instead ... but probably most importantly, I had changed.
It's really hard to believe when I say it out loud. I think we live our day to day lives, never stopping to think about it except on the most rare of occasions. I'm leaving people behind. I'm moving on from wading through forum posts looking for a laugh. It's strange. It feels weird. I'm uncertain.
I think this is what it means to grow up.
Without a doubt, I'll miss them. Foosball club will of course not be the same. We're a dying breed, so to speak. The two of them represent a full third of our regular members. I'm don't really interact with them outside of the foosball tables, and with my recent boycott of facebook, keeping in touch will be difficult. So when they walked in the opposite direction to their homes, it occurred to me that I would probably never see them again.
Plopping myself down in front of my computer, I clicked through the three sites I check on a regular basis now: chessgames.com, riveraveblues.com, and teamliquid.net.
According to my profile, I registered an account on Teamliquid (TL) on October 4, 2008. I lurked the forums for a few months prior to that, so it's been almost three years since I first visited. At the time it was a close-knit group, focused on the professional scene of Korean Starcraft. There were the forum giants, who had accumulated 20,000 posts over 6 years. There were the villains of the board, who sought to "troll" at every given opportunity. It was a site to fall in love with because of its familiarity and common goal: forming a community.
Thousands upon thousands of man-hours went into that site. Whether it was a comprehensive analysis of the latest "revolution" in Terran versus Zerg or an endless list of "yo mama" jokes filled with the most topical Korean Broodwar references, the posts all had a cleverness and a certain charm behind them. I spent hours reading the forums. TL became my source for all news - not just the Starcraft variety. I knew that someone would always have an interesting take, or something funny to say, or at the very least, some lively debate to kick off.
I'll never say that all the time I've spent reading TL were wasted. They didn't really get me many places, per se. I'm not a better mathematician because of them. I'm probably not even a more informed person. All those hours run completely contrary to common definitions of productivity. So maybe it wasn't the best use of time.
Claiming that all that time was useless, however, could not be further from the truth. I learned so much about people. I was taught how to see the funny things in life. I saw first-hand where effort and determination could get you. I was inspired by the people dedicating their lives to an online service that was free of charge, all for the sake of a single passion.
But today I came home, sad at the prospect of never seeing the seniors again. Sad, but not crushed. People come and go in our lives, this much is inevitable. And as hard as it is to say, not everyone can be with us forever. So I thought to myself - if I can say goodbye to Steve and David, can't I say goodbye to TL?
It was a startling connection to make. Why would I stop visiting the site I've probably spent more than 10 hours per week on for the last 3 years? It's not like I was being forced into the situation, the way the departure of the seniors was forced upon me. The reasons were blatantly obvious, though. The community had changed, there were many new members, there are a whole host of things I should be doing instead ... but probably most importantly, I had changed.
It's really hard to believe when I say it out loud. I think we live our day to day lives, never stopping to think about it except on the most rare of occasions. I'm leaving people behind. I'm moving on from wading through forum posts looking for a laugh. It's strange. It feels weird. I'm uncertain.
I think this is what it means to grow up.
Monday, May 2, 2011
In general I do not attempt to attack anything on this blog. So I'll preface this with the fact that I do not mean to insult anyone with this post. What I say is personal preference. It does not apply to everyone. I only ask that you consider what I say in a serious and critical manner.
Facebook bothers me. Every word I read on it seems so fake, so artificial, so contrived. All geared toward presenting a personality that is incomplete. Every single feature does an excellent job of highlighting the most irrelevant and useless details about a person. Why on earth is "friend count" displayed, and in such a prominent location? I literally cannot think of a single reason. Why do they count the number of "likes" on a post, count the number of pictures that you're tagged in? Complete garbage, all of it. The worst of it is, I see people I highly respect falling for this popularity contest. I do not mean to judge. I've just seen myself ... under its influence, for lack of a better word.
In short, it brings out the worst in people. It may be suited for other people. I don't mean to imply I'm better than them, or anything of the sort. But in my case in particular, when I look at my profile I see something that isn't representative of me at all. And I find it hard to believe that a simple profile or a series of jokes and links could ever hope to represent a person. We are far more complex, far more intelligent, and far more difficult to understand than that.
Facebook bothers me. Every word I read on it seems so fake, so artificial, so contrived. All geared toward presenting a personality that is incomplete. Every single feature does an excellent job of highlighting the most irrelevant and useless details about a person. Why on earth is "friend count" displayed, and in such a prominent location? I literally cannot think of a single reason. Why do they count the number of "likes" on a post, count the number of pictures that you're tagged in? Complete garbage, all of it. The worst of it is, I see people I highly respect falling for this popularity contest. I do not mean to judge. I've just seen myself ... under its influence, for lack of a better word.
In short, it brings out the worst in people. It may be suited for other people. I don't mean to imply I'm better than them, or anything of the sort. But in my case in particular, when I look at my profile I see something that isn't representative of me at all. And I find it hard to believe that a simple profile or a series of jokes and links could ever hope to represent a person. We are far more complex, far more intelligent, and far more difficult to understand than that.
Thursday, April 7, 2011
Professionalism, continued
Here's a conversation I had recently.
me: not worth the hours upon hours of programming time that went into that projectI'll be the first to admit that I have a tendency to write "pretty" things without complete justification. I do like my posts to look “pretty,” and I always welcome challenges to my conclusions. But I also think there's validity to what I'm saying, so feel free to object to what I say, and criticize my penchant for high-minded and romantic ideals.
me: like
it's a good idea
me: and lots of people will use it
probably
and it'll make a lot of money
so good for them
but essentially useless for everyone else
Person: so something has to help people to be worth doing?
me: doesn't it?
Person: i suppose so
me: there are so many people in the world
that need so much help
we don't go off and help them
or donate all our money to them
but the least we can do is work toward something
that will help people in the future
not create shiny products that will make us lots of money
Person: well darn
there goes my plan
me: it's not like programmers can't do useful stuf
it's just that 90% of them don't.
Person: true
me: like
started out as one of these kinds of things
but then they expanded
to do so much more
they use their influence so responsibly
but that's one of thousands of startups
with such ultimately useless projects
even facebook falls under this category to some extent
Person: yeah
me: didn't you read my blog
Person: what
which blog
me: the last post
Person: yeah
it sounded legit
me: but that was the point
Person: oh
somehow i kinda missed the extent of it
me: what
dangit
Person: well
you started writing pretty stuff
that sounds nice
but i'm not sure i believe
me: wat
which part
Person: "Well, because I've always felt that we owed it to humanity itself. As melodramatic and romantic as that sounds, it's what I believe. We owe it to ... ourselves ... to dedicate our lives to making this world a better place."
dude
helping people is good
however
why is it our purpose
me: because if we don't do it, who will
Person: no one
is that bad?
me: yes
we got rich off society
how is it fair that we just go around and do nothing to help other people
Person: i dunno
what is fair
me: it's fair that everyone gets an equal shot at being happy
which is not even remotely close to true right now
Person: oh
that actually sounds pretty legit
i can agree with that mostly
but like
then i can ask why it matters if people are happy
me: because it's what everyone wants
Person: but why does it matter what people want
i'll skip a step
why does it matter that there are people
i mean
i don't mean to be annoying
or anything
but like
any argument about things like what are people meant to do
relies on like
meaning of liife
type of stuff
in my opinion, at least
me: that's probably true
but we're here
we have a lot of time
with which to do stuff
we all kill ourselves right now
and it wouldn't make the slightest difference
Person: so we define winning conditions for life?
and kinda agree upon them to the best of our ability?
me: more or less
you can argue that there's no "fair" or "right" or "wrong"
and i can't conclusively prove you wrong
but i feel like all of those arguments are hypocritical at best
because no one will ever willingly do what they're saying
Person: true
interesting
the fact that we have wills gives us all of those concepts
me: what do you mean
Person: well
if nobody wanted anything
there wouldn't be 'happy'
me: true
Thursday, March 17, 2011
Professionalism
People do not seem to realize that their opinion of the world is also a confession of character.
– Ralph Waldo Emerson
It's kind of funny where I happened upon that quote. Funny, in the sense that I never would have expected it. I came across it in the middle of Technical Communications for Computer Scientists (Tech Comm), while I was busy not paying attention. Instead, I was reading the argument over who was the best Super Smash Brothers: Melee player in the world. What the person who posted that was thinking, I'm not quite sure.
But as I grudgingly turned my attention to the debate going on in class, I saw exactly what Emerson meant. The professor was presenting a study, conducted by a professor at CMU itself, that suggested that the students at CMU aren't actually under as much stress as they so frequently report. The study suggested that students merely feel guilty about not doing their work and cite misleading examples such as cram sessions and all-nighters as evidence of their work.
I nodded my head. I definitely recognized the accuracy in many of these statements. The class, however, vehemently disagreed. In the words of one student, they "took umbrage" at the study. They pointed out flaws. They suggested that the organizers didn't understand what it meant to be stressed. They said that time spent on work was not an accurate representation of the pressure one was under. They suggested that the job of the student was inherently more stressful because the results they produced dictated their future. Many students even went insofar as to state that CMU was more stressful than other schools of similar, lower, or even higher reputation.
Disgusted. I have never been more ashamed of my peers than I was while sitting in that room. I truly, truly hate to judge people, but this is what I felt. I saw then what the problem was. When we first got here, they warned us that while we used to be big fish in a small pond, now we would all be little fish in a big pond. Nothing wrong with that. Almost everyone has to be humbled at some point. But rather, the attitude that persists here is that while we are all little fish in a big pond, every fish in our pond would be the biggest fish anywhere else.
That, however, was not the extent of the problem. The comment about how a student's position is inherently more stressful struck deep. I finally understood why I didn't belong with these people.
I will, of course, not generalize. There are many CS majors with a love of their studies. But many, if not most, are uninterested in what they do here. They don't study computer science for the computer science. It's their greatest dream to get out of here, get a high-paying job as a programmer, and move on with their lives. There's nothing wrong with this, per se. How can I blame people who aren't interested in their work? How can I blame people who want to use their education as a means to make money to feed their happiness?
But while I can't blame them, I can see a fundamental difference of opinion. Maybe (probably) it's because both my parents were academics. What obligation do we have to enjoy what we do? Why can't our professional lives and our personal lives be totally separate entities? What's wrong with working 9-5, or whenever, and going home to live a different life afterward? Why is it a requirement that our profession be more than just a means of financial stability?
Well, because I've always felt that we owed it to humanity itself. As melodramatic and romantic as that sounds, it's what I believe. We owe it to ... ourselves ... to dedicate our lives to making this world a better place. There are so many ways to do that. We can teach, we can contribute to science, we can mediate, we can even study biology (although this should be a last resort). The possibilities are indeed endless.
Conveniently enough, through this mission to improve the world around us, we improve ourselves. We reach this strange point where what we do is both selfish and selfless - that we work to improve the world, but do it in a way that satisfies us. It's a beautiful compromise. One that takes years to find and a lifetime to complete. I can't help but feel sad when I see a life dedicated to some other cause. If nothing else, we owe it to the people before us, who have worked so hard and brought us so far.
We all have so much talent, so much time, and so much to offer. Every single one of us has the potential to change the world for the better. It's up to us to fulfill that potential.
– Ralph Waldo Emerson
It's kind of funny where I happened upon that quote. Funny, in the sense that I never would have expected it. I came across it in the middle of Technical Communications for Computer Scientists (Tech Comm), while I was busy not paying attention. Instead, I was reading the argument over who was the best Super Smash Brothers: Melee player in the world. What the person who posted that was thinking, I'm not quite sure.
But as I grudgingly turned my attention to the debate going on in class, I saw exactly what Emerson meant. The professor was presenting a study, conducted by a professor at CMU itself, that suggested that the students at CMU aren't actually under as much stress as they so frequently report. The study suggested that students merely feel guilty about not doing their work and cite misleading examples such as cram sessions and all-nighters as evidence of their work.
I nodded my head. I definitely recognized the accuracy in many of these statements. The class, however, vehemently disagreed. In the words of one student, they "took umbrage" at the study. They pointed out flaws. They suggested that the organizers didn't understand what it meant to be stressed. They said that time spent on work was not an accurate representation of the pressure one was under. They suggested that the job of the student was inherently more stressful because the results they produced dictated their future. Many students even went insofar as to state that CMU was more stressful than other schools of similar, lower, or even higher reputation.
Disgusted. I have never been more ashamed of my peers than I was while sitting in that room. I truly, truly hate to judge people, but this is what I felt. I saw then what the problem was. When we first got here, they warned us that while we used to be big fish in a small pond, now we would all be little fish in a big pond. Nothing wrong with that. Almost everyone has to be humbled at some point. But rather, the attitude that persists here is that while we are all little fish in a big pond, every fish in our pond would be the biggest fish anywhere else.
That, however, was not the extent of the problem. The comment about how a student's position is inherently more stressful struck deep. I finally understood why I didn't belong with these people.
I will, of course, not generalize. There are many CS majors with a love of their studies. But many, if not most, are uninterested in what they do here. They don't study computer science for the computer science. It's their greatest dream to get out of here, get a high-paying job as a programmer, and move on with their lives. There's nothing wrong with this, per se. How can I blame people who aren't interested in their work? How can I blame people who want to use their education as a means to make money to feed their happiness?
But while I can't blame them, I can see a fundamental difference of opinion. Maybe (probably) it's because both my parents were academics. What obligation do we have to enjoy what we do? Why can't our professional lives and our personal lives be totally separate entities? What's wrong with working 9-5, or whenever, and going home to live a different life afterward? Why is it a requirement that our profession be more than just a means of financial stability?
Well, because I've always felt that we owed it to humanity itself. As melodramatic and romantic as that sounds, it's what I believe. We owe it to ... ourselves ... to dedicate our lives to making this world a better place. There are so many ways to do that. We can teach, we can contribute to science, we can mediate, we can even study biology (although this should be a last resort). The possibilities are indeed endless.
Conveniently enough, through this mission to improve the world around us, we improve ourselves. We reach this strange point where what we do is both selfish and selfless - that we work to improve the world, but do it in a way that satisfies us. It's a beautiful compromise. One that takes years to find and a lifetime to complete. I can't help but feel sad when I see a life dedicated to some other cause. If nothing else, we owe it to the people before us, who have worked so hard and brought us so far.
We all have so much talent, so much time, and so much to offer. Every single one of us has the potential to change the world for the better. It's up to us to fulfill that potential.
Wednesday, February 16, 2011
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
